Five daughters, one son–two families

O.S. Neal was the only son in a family with five girls. He married Nellie Keith, who was the oldest of five daughters in a family with only one son.

O.S. and Nellie Neal and family, L-R: O.S. (Orlando Swain), Mary Margaret (Neal) Lenocker, Kenneth Neal (my grandfather), Nellie (Keith) Neal, Keith John Neal, Maurice Marshall (M.M.) Neal (Mary Margaret’s twin).

The Keiths

I discovered this photo (below) of the John Washington Keith and Mary (Harkin) Keith photo on findagrave. Nellie Edith is the oldest daughter. I think she may be standing, second one from left.

The label with the photo says that in the back row, the first person is Mabel Marcella Keith, with George Keith center back. The young girl in the middle is listed as “Sade.” Front: George Washington Keith and Mary Harkins [sic] Keith. Mary Harkin was born in Canada, as her parents headed to the United States from Ireland.

I wonder if the person who posted this photo on John Washington Keith’s findagrave page noticed that John is called George on the photo. Anything you find on findagrave should be used only as clues to locate better documents.

John W. and Mary Keith family. Mabel Marcella Keith is on the left, George B. Keith standing center, the youngest is Sadie Keith. (There was another daughter, Idella Regina Keith, who died as a child in 1881.)

Nellie Edith Keith married O.S. (Orlando Swain) Neal, the only son of John and Rhoda (Marshall) Neal. (John Neal was a Civil War veteran. Several of Rhoda’s brothers also served.)

The Neals

Back: Dora Ellen (Neal) Andrew, Hannah Jane (Neal) Doling), Ida Minerva (Neal) Andrew, Nancy Belle (Neal) Andrew, Cynthia Magnolia (Neal) Miller Front: Rhoda L. (Marshall) Neal, Orlando Swain “O.S.” Neal, John Neal

Yes, three of Neal sisters married three Andrew brothers. Do you suppose those sisters spoiled their younger brother?


More about O.S. Neal

18 comments

  1. This is fascinating stuff, Joy! As a first-generation Canadian, daughter of Jewish immigrants from eastern Europe, much of my family history has been lost. (I think I told you that before.) My husband’s Irish roots have been traced and are equally fascinating. I get my own history vicariously. Of course, as a child of God, I have a very large family, don’t I? How are you feeling?

    • And here I am so blessed with ancestor stories. I’m 7 weeks out from my last infusion. One week to the next! Doing amazingly well, and so thankful. Exhausted, but no longer miserable. How are you doing?

      • I’m so glad to hear that you’re getting some relief from the infusions. Prayers for more from the next one. I seem to be OK. I’m trying to be patient as I wait for a date for my shoulder surgery. Other sources of pain test my patience, though. Trust in the Lord to strengthen my resolve to do lots of pre-surgery exercise!

  2. Wow! I love what you uncover, Joy! On Paul’s side of the family we found a couple of generations of sisters and brothers marrying into the same families. Much more common, once upon a time. Love these photos. Treasures! 🥰❤️🥰

Leave a Reply to Eilene LyonCancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.